1. I am a comic artist, and probably won't buy papers that can't be used to make comics.
and
2. I have a limited budget.
Since I was testing paper, I decided to break out the collection of inks I've amassed, killing two birds with one stone.
Inks Tested:
Speedball Calligraphy Ink
Winsor Newton India Ink
Speedball Super Black
Sumi (not sure what brand)
Higgins Black Magic
Koh-i-noor (typically used in Rapidograph tech pens)
FW Acrylic Ink
Bombay India Ink
Papers tested with all inks:
500 Series Bristol (Vellum Surface, 2 ply)
500 Series Bristol (Plate Surface, 2 ply)
400 Series Drawing, Medium Surface, 80 lb
Papers tested with 2 best inks (these were trading card size, so I couldn't fit everything)
300 Semi Smooth Bristol
300 Smooth
300 Vellum
200 Smooth
500 Illustration Board
Waterfastness test- 500 Series Vellum
I tested a variety of conditions, including-
Copic fastness
Ability to cover blue lead (both the pencil and lead kind)
Erasibility (plastic, sand, and electric)
and ability to cover graphite
I tested with both a nib (spoon nib) and a brush
![]() |
| E.E= Electric Eraser (Sakura brand), E.S= Sand Eraser, E.P= Plastic Eraser BL Uni= Blue Lead, Unicolor (Mechanical Lead), GR=Graphite |
My recommendations: None of these inks are really Copic-proof (The Koh-i-nor comes the closest), so if you do a lot of marker illustrations, you should probably use Multiliners since those ARE Copic safe. None of the inks had major problems with erasing (a bit of a shame with the sand eraser, since those are meant to pick up ink), and a surprising number of inks are not water safe. My favorite ink of this bunch is the Bombay India Ink, and my favorite inking paper is still Strathmore 500 series Plate. I think the illustration board is really nice and heavy, and can probably stand up to watercolor.









